vp19 (vp19) wrote in carole_and_co,

  • Mood:

Not the real deal

Carole Lombard looks a bit perturbed here in this still -- according to a reader of this blog, it's from "The Princess Comes Across," her 1936 Paramount comedy-mystery -- and based upon someone's apparent action at eBay, somewhere in the afterlife she feels perturbed, too.

What would she be upset about? An autograph that turned out to be a fake (not shown here for that reason). I asked Carole Sampeck of The Lombard Archive, the unquestioned authority on Lombard signatures, and her response was: "In the words of the guard at the Wizard's compound: Not no way, not no how. Not even close. They did make a valiant attempt, but no cigar."

The autograph's style doesn't look authentic, and adding to the skepticism is a statement to the right of the signature, which supposedly came from "an old autograph book at an estate sale several years ago," reading, "1938 or 39? Met Carole on a flight to California from Indiana."

I'm pretty certain Lombard never visited Indiana in '38 or '39; it certainly would have been noted in the press at the time and documented in Wes D. Gehring's fine, Indiana-centered biography of the actress, "Carole Lombard: The Hoosier Tornado." (She may have traveled through the state, and it's possible a flight may have made a stop there, but I'm sure that between the 1930 Fort Wayne visit and the '42 Indy bond rally, she never had Indiana as a destination.)

In short, this autograph simply isn't genuine, and apparently collectors are skeptical, too. The minimum bid for this item (signed in pencil) is an absurdly low $9.99, and no one has bitten. To be fair, the seller isn't entirely sure of its authenticity, either, making this comment: "Looks real, but I don't know. If you are an expert please let me know."

Oh, and Carole has one further comment of her own:

She was tempted to make a stronger gesture, but we dissuaded her.

Recent Posts from This Community

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment